How Are Baseball Gloves and Softball Gloves Different?

July 29 2024, by Brad Purcell, 13 min reading time

Baseball and softball are closely related sports, but they have key differences that extend beyond the size of the ball and the dynamics of the game. One such difference lies in the equipment used, particularly the gloves. If you’ve ever wondered how baseball gloves and softball gloves differ, you’re not alone. Understanding these differences is crucial for players looking to optimize their performance and comfort on the field.

In this blog, we explain the specific design variations between baseball and softball gloves, including size, pocket depth, and webbing. Whether you're a player, coach, or an avid fan, this guide will help you understand why these distinctions matter and how choosing the right glove can impact your game.

Discover the Perfect Destination to Buy Gloves for Baseball and Softball

With a comprehensive selection of top brands and new arrivals, Baseball 360 offers everything you need to elevate your game. We carry a wide range of brands including Adidas, Easton, Louisville, Nike, Rawlings, Wilson, and many more. Whether you need infield gloves, outfield gloves, catchers' mitts, or first-base gloves, we have it all.

Shop for Baseball Gear Online

The Biggest Differences Between Baseball and Softball Gloves

Whether you are an avid baseball player or a dedicated softball player, understanding the major differences between these gloves can enhance your performance on the field. From leather quality to pocket depth and webbing style, each feature plays a crucial role in the game's dynamics.

Glove Design and Purpose

Baseball gloves and softball gloves are tailored to accommodate the varying dynamics of each sport.

Baseball Gloves: These gloves are typically smaller, ranging from 9 inches for youth gloves to 13 inches for adult outfielders gloves.
Softball Gloves: Due to the larger size of the softball, these gloves are larger, with a standard size ranging from 12 to 15 inches.

Pocket Size and Depth

Baseball Gloves: Designed with a shallower pocket to facilitate quick ball transfer, essential for impressive fielding plays and double plays.
Softball Gloves: Feature larger pockets to secure the bigger, heavier softball, with deeper pocket designs enhancing ball control.

Player Position and Glove Type

Baseball Infielders: Use gloves with a shallow pocket and narrow webbing to enable fast ball retrieval and quick throws.
Softball Infielders: Prefer gloves with a slightly deeper pocket to accommodate the larger ball while still allowing for quick plays.

Baseball Outfield Gloves: Usually have a deep pocket and a longer length (up to 13 inches) for catching fly balls.
Softball Outfield Gloves: Larger and deeper to handle the 11-inch softball, offering better ball retention during catches.

Catcher's Mitts and First Base Mitts

Baseball Catcher's Mitts: Smaller circumference with more padding to catch fast pitches.
Softball Catcher's Mitts: Larger circumference and deeper pocket to manage the larger ball size.

Types of Webbing

Baseball Gloves: Often feature closed webbing for pitchers to conceal their grip or basket web gloves for infielders.
Softball Gloves: Utilize open webbing styles to enhance visibility and ease of catching.

Wrist Straps and Finger Stalls

Baseball Gloves: Usually equipped with an adjustable wrist Velcro strap for a snug fit and narrower fingers to allow for better control.
Softball Gloves: Often feature a larger wrist opening and wider finger stalls to accommodate different hand sizes, ensuring comfort and performance.

Padding and Protection

Softball gloves are designed with regular padding and sometimes additional padding due to the sport's larger, heavier ball. Baseball gloves, on the other hand, prioritize agility and quick movements with less padding.

How to Clean Baseball Gloves and Store Them

What Is the Ideal Type of Glove for Every Position?

In both baseball and softball, different positions require specific types of gloves to optimize performance and meet the unique demands of each role on the field. Here’s a breakdown of the various positions and the corresponding types of gloves used:

Baseball Positions and Gloves

Pitcher

Glove Type: Pitcher's Glove
Features: Typically has a closed web to conceal grip on the ball, average size (11.5 to 12 inches).

Catcher

Glove Type: Catcher's Mitt
Features: Heavily padded, no individual fingers, usually larger in circumference (32.5 to 34 inches) to handle fast pitches.

First Baseman

Glove Type: First Baseman's Mitt
Features: Long and deep pocket, with a curved edge to help scoop balls, larger in size (12 to 13 inches).

Middle Infielders (Second Base and Shortstop)

Glove Type: Middle Infielder's Glove
Features: Smaller size (11 to 11.75 inches), shallow and narrow pocket for quick transfers.

Third Baseman

Glove Type: Third Baseman's Glove
Features: Slightly larger than middle infielder's gloves (11.5 to 12 inches), stiffer, and with a deeper pocket to handle hard-hit balls.

Outfielders (Left Field, Center Field, Right Field)

Glove Type: Outfielder's Glove
Features: Larger gloves (12 to 13 inches), deeper pocket to catch fly balls.

Softball Positions and Gloves

Pitcher

Glove Type: Pitcher's Glove
Features: Similar to a baseball pitcher's glove, often a bit larger (12 to 12.5 inches) to accommodate the larger softball, closed webbing.

Catcher

Glove Type: Catcher's Mitt
Features: Larger and more padded than a baseball catcher's mitt, usually around 33 to 35 inches in circumference.

First Baseman

Glove Type: First Baseman's Mitt
Features: Similar to baseball, but larger to handle the softball (12.5 to 13 inches), deep pocket.

Middle Infielders (Second Base and Shortstop)

Glove Type: Middle Infielder's Glove
Features: Larger than baseball infield gloves (11.5 to 12.5 inches), shallow pocket for quick throws.

Third Baseman

Glove Type: Third Baseman's Glove
Features: Larger and sturdier than middle infield gloves (12 to 12.5 inches), deep pocket.

Outfielders (Left Field, Center Field, Right Field)

Glove Type: Outfielder's Glove
Features: Largest gloves on the field (12.5 to 14 inches), deep pocket for catching fly balls.

Mastering the Field: The Ultimate Guide to Slowpitch Softball Gloves

Tips for Choosing the Right Baseball Glove

Selecting the right baseball glove can significantly enhance your performance on the field. Here are some key tips to help you choose the perfect glove for your needs:

Understand Regulation Requirements

Regulation Baseball: Ensure the glove meets the size and design standards for your league.
Regulation Softball: Different regulations apply for softball gloves, particularly in fastpitch softball.

Style of Webbing

The type of webbing affects visibility and flexibility.

Closed Pocket: Ideal for pitchers to hide the ball.
Solid Webbing: Common in infield gloves to help with ball visibility.
Standard Webbing: Offers a balance of visibility and flexibility.

Size and Fit

Glove Size: Match the glove size to your position and personal comfort.

Youth Baseball Gloves: Typically smaller (9 to 11 inches) to fit young hands.
Adult Baseball Gloves: Range from 11 to 13 inches based on position.

Fitting Glove: Ensure a snug fit with adjustable wrist straps and secure the glove on your hand.
Inch Glove: Check the inch measurement for your position's requirements.

Construction and Material

Strip of Leather: High-quality leather offers durability and better performance.
Padded Pocket: Look for extra padding in the pocket for better ball control.
Firm Pocket: A firmer pocket can help maintain shape and durability over time.

By considering these tips, you'll be well-equipped to choose the right glove for your game.

Finding the Winning Fit: How To Choose The Right Size Baseball Glove